Chidambaram presents a 'politically correct budget' for 2007-08 - Instablogs
Chidambaram presents a 'politically correct budget' for 2007-08
Balendu , Delhi: Feb 28 2007
Made Popular Feb 28 2007

Chidambaram presents a 'politically correct budget' for 2007-08

Indian Finance Minister P. Chidambaram has presented the Annual Budget 2007-2008 uninterrupted, despite high chances of furor during budget presentation. Amid scores of several issues pertaining to the Indian economy, the primary focus of the newly presented budget was laid on the farm sector. The Finance Minister said that agriculture had grown by 2.3 percent on average in the last three years against a target of 4 percent. The budget has envisaged rising spending on health and education and focused on accelerating the deteriorating agricultural economy in an effort to ensure growth for a majority of population.

The Finance Minister presented his fourth budget since repossessing the ministry three years back. This time he was not the same minister who a decade back had presented the dream budget. Chidambaram presented his budget amid mounting pressure to step up spending while curbing prices to assure voters that this government can work in their favor. In addition to it, the budget was unveiled just ahead of more state assembly elections.

While eyeing on state elections this year and on national elections due in 2009, the budget raised spending on education by 34.2 percent in the coming financial year. At the same time, health and family welfare spending rose by 21.9 percent with an assurance to expand rural job guarantee scheme. The minister also promised to take measures to control inflation, which is hovering slightly below its highest level in more than two years. He also announced increased water and fertiliser subsidies for farmers.

Government spending on infrastructure including ports, power generation and roads will be lifted by 40 percent to 1.34 trillion rupees ($30.2 billion) in the next fiscal year, Chidambaram told parliament. Better infrastructure may see more companies follow Nissan Motor Co. and Renault SA, which are investing in setting up factories in India.

Moreover, India’s $854 billion economy decelerated to the slowest pace in a year last quarter, the Central Statistical Organisation said in a statement. The government is expecting a 9.2 percent expansion in the year to March 31, the fastest pace since 1989.

The Finance Minister appeared to be slightly unfriendly with the IT and BPO in this budget as it has proposed to tax 11.22 percent of the adjusted book profits as Minimum Alternative Tax (MAT). The latest proposal can knock off 1.5 percent of Infosys’ profitability.


On the tax front
, the budget is a mix bag for individuals, corporates and those investing in the markets. Marginal relief has been provided to individuals by raising the exemption limit by Rs 10,000, while the corporate income tax has not been changed. The securities transaction tax has been left unchanged; however, the dividend distribution tax has been lifted by 2.5 percent. For the professionals, the payout in form of Fringe Benefit Tax is inevitable to be higher in case he or she is receiver of stock options.

Indian industry has expressed deep discontent and disappointment over the Budget for 2007-08. The industry raised the concern on lack of measures to increase productivity and for losing an opportunity to provide relief to the corporate sector. CII president, R Sesashayee, has pointed out that since revenues from peak customs and excise were increasing, this could have been a time to reduce excise duty to 20 per cent, if not 15 per cent overall, which would have been in line with Kelkar Committee Report.

FICCI President Habil Khorakiwala, too seemed to be greatly dissatisfied as he said, a wrong signal has gone to the corporate world as the government has increased cess and dividend distribution tax. He further reacted sharply saying,

One does not understand how the multiple taxes should be charged. I think the feeling of the chamber is that the Finance Minister has lost an opportunity of providing relief to the corporate world.

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
0 Stars
The budget report has always been a mix bag for individuals buddy. Well, I would like to know whether the new budget had considered the issue of bringing ”internet” to the rural areas since blogging has caught the pace in India and it will reach the new heights if and only if there is internet access in every nook and corner of the Indian states.
0 Stars
Indian Finance Minister P. Chidambaram has grown into the most influential finance minister India has ever produced – under his reign no doubt there has been persistent rise in the price level but the fact that cannot be denied is that the economy has grown over 8 percent.

The continuation of the overall trend of moderating taxes was expected in the budget for the next financial year – the outcome of the budget perhaps benefits the individuals as the exemption limit has been raised by Rs 10,000. However, yet again the corporate sector will be on the back foot.

The Indian economy has taken off and moved from a phase of moderate growth to a new phase of high growth, with an expected gross domestic product (GDP) expansion of 9.2 percent. Still the biggest sector (agricultural sector) has been growing at the slowest rate.

The primary focus of the newly presented budget is laid on the agricultural sector agreed but here I think again the policy is one side (something that has happened in the past). Then, the Farm sector was secondary and now the corporate sector. It would have been beneficial had a balance been struck – coz no sector of the economy can grow individually.

Inflation is the imp that needed to be curbed – the shortage on the supply side is responsible for the inflationary pressure in the country i.e. Poor agricultural produce and lack of essential consumption commodities (that inflates the price) – I hope the benefits to the agricultural sector can help the nation avoid the plague.
0 Stars
The rural sector accounts for two-thirds of India but is growing at less than 1/3rd of the pace of the growth rate of overall economy. Budget is silent over the steps the government has taken for the welfare for the rural India. Many of the funds do not reach their target because of poor implementation, lack of developmental will power and corruption. Government should work for the netter implementation of the projects announced in the budget.
0 Stars
Unemployment, education and social sector were critical areas pre-budget - the budget has raised spending on education by 34.2 percent while health and family welfare spending by 21.9 percent.

For health as well as education it seems insufficient
0 Stars
Poor agriculture performance has been the root cause for inflation in the country, if the sector can benefit from the budget the high rising prices can surely be checked. Apart from the minimum benefit for the corporate sector, overall the budget is economically appropriate.
0 Stars
I just read the entire Annual Budget 2007-08 now a few minutes back and came come to the following conclusion:

a) Chidambaram has lost his marbles.
b) This Budget does nothing for the Corporate Sector, neither the Great Indian Middleclass.
c) The ’politics’ of the whole issue seemed to have lost the plot. Else, we would have seen some more sops.
d) Silver lining - The Congress is on the exit path.

The reason for my sarcasm is that this proposal is beyond any sane comprehension. What new have we seen here, and if spending on women health and welfare, infrastructure etc is concerned, that should be taken for granted by the Indian public for such things are long due for the country.

Having said that, I would like to ask all the readers here. Do we really need an annual budget like this? Many developed and developing countries do not have it. As the GACL Managing Director said yesterday in a newspaper interview - The Union Budget is a good revenue model for the media, and I subscribe fully to this school of thought.

This is really a circus that the governments of this unfortunate country holds every year hoping that it would improve its prospects to rule longer.

Anyway, coming back to the Union Budget 2007-08 again, I am at a loss on what to say. I just hope that Chidambaram succeeds in scoring the self goal that it valiantly attempted.

The CSI, CII and other industrial bodies are a disgruntled lot as the middleclass is. Not only that, as Pratyush said, the rural sector is again shortchanged.

If at all anyone is happy about it, it is Leo my mate’s Doberman whose food just became cheaper. But hang on, would my mate, who is a middleclass citizen of this country, be able to buy extra food for Leo?

Give a thought on this.
0 Stars
PARAG
mumbai, India
Mr. FM we dont want you to shuffle the percentage increase and decrease in all sectors, we are looking for something more substantial. We need a budget which caters to all classes the agriculturist, the service class, the urban class and the money makers(businessmen). It is primarily the service class and urban class who end up paying majority of the taxes, we need to get as much as we give to the govt. which unfortunately is never the case. Lets focus on the basics first inflation which is effecting daily eatables, power which is insufficient, water which is always in shortage, fuel (pet/diesel) the prices always head in one direction. We talk of India as a growing economy but the state infrastructure still leaves a lot to be desired from and SEZ’s are not the only solution. We expect a lot more from a man of your stature and experience.
Add your Comment